Which Thinking Tool Should You Use?
Three frameworks. Each designed for a different type of stuck thought. Find the right one for what you're working through.
The Three Frameworks at a Glance
CBT Thought Record
Open tool →A 7-step structured worksheet that examines a specific automatic thought against evidence. Best for anxious predictions, self-critical thoughts, and cognitive distortions. The most-studied CBT self-help tool.
Best for: anxiety, self-criticism, catastrophizing, distorted thinking
Socratic Questioning
Open tool →A structured inquiry that examines the assumptions underneath a belief. Rather than testing evidence for one thought, it uncovers the deeper reasoning. Best for complex beliefs, decisions, and long-held assumptions.
Best for: decisions, limiting beliefs, complex assumptions
The Work (Byron Katie Method)
Open tool →Four questions that examine whether a painful belief is actually true — and a "turnaround" that inverts the belief to reveal alternative interpretations. Best for past events, interpersonal suffering, and beliefs about how things "should" be.
Best for: rumination, resentment, interpersonal pain, "should" beliefs
Match Your Thought Type to the Right Tool
Find the description that most closely matches what you're experiencing:
An anxious thought about something that might happen
You're predicting a bad outcome and can't stop playing through worst-case scenarios.
The CBT thought record is the most direct tool for anxious predictions. It examines the evidence for the worst-case scenario versus the actual range of likely outcomes. Socratic questioning also works well for underlying beliefs that drive the anxiety.
Replaying something that already happened
You keep going back to a past conversation, decision, or event — and can't let it go.
The Work is specifically designed for past-focused beliefs. Its four questions directly address the pattern of replaying — especially when the event involved another person's behavior. The CBT thought record works as an alternative for examining what the replay is claiming.
Can't make a decision — stuck in analysis
You keep weighing options and can't commit. More analysis doesn't help.
Recommended
Try Socratic QuestioningDecision paralysis is usually driven by an underlying belief about what a wrong choice would mean. Socratic questioning uncovers that belief and examines whether it's accurate — which makes the decision much easier. The CBT thought record is less suited for decisions.
A harsh self-critical thought about who you are
You believe something negative about yourself — your competence, worth, or character.
Self-critical thoughts are often stated as facts ('I am incompetent') when they're actually conclusions drawn from specific events. The CBT thought record is effective at examining the evidence behind these conclusions. The Work works well when the self-criticism is tied to a belief about what others think of you.
Anger, resentment, or hurt about someone else
You're stuck on something another person did or said — and can't release it.
Recommended
Try The WorkThe Work is the strongest tool for interpersonal suffering. Its turnaround technique — applying the belief to yourself instead — reveals how the belief you hold about another person is often a projection of a belief about yourself.
A deeply held belief that might be limiting you
Something you've assumed is true for years — about yourself, others, or how the world works.
Socratic questioning is designed for beliefs that haven't been examined — not just individual thoughts but the frameworks through which you interpret experience. It's the most appropriate tool for assumptions you've never questioned.
Quick Comparison
| Situation | Best Tool |
|---|---|
| Anxious thought about an upcoming event | CBT Thought Record |
| Replaying a past conversation | The Work |
| Stuck on a difficult decision | Socratic Questioning |
| Self-critical thought ("I am bad at this") | CBT Thought Record |
| Anger or resentment toward someone | The Work |
| Long-held belief you've never examined | Socratic Questioning |
| Catastrophizing about a worst-case scenario | CBT Thought Record |
| Can't let a past relationship go | The Work |
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between CBT, Socratic questioning, and The Work?
CBT thought records examine whether a thought is accurate by comparing it against evidence. Socratic questioning examines the assumptions and premises underneath a belief through structured questions. Byron Katie's The Work examines whether a painful belief is true and what would happen without it. All three are evidence-based — they just approach thought examination from different angles.
When should I use a CBT thought record?
Use a CBT thought record when you have a specific anxious, shameful, or catastrophic thought you want to examine. It works best for thoughts that feel factual but might be distorted — thoughts about your performance, others' opinions of you, or worst-case outcomes. The 7-step structure makes it effective for well-defined automatic thoughts.
When should I use Socratic questioning?
Use Socratic questioning when you're facing a decision, holding a belief you've never examined, or feel stuck in a particular view. It's better than the CBT thought record for complex, multi-layered beliefs where you need to explore what's underneath rather than just examine evidence for and against a single thought.
When should I use Byron Katie's The Work?
Use The Work when you're experiencing suffering related to another person's behavior, a past event you can't let go of, or a belief about how things 'should' be. The four questions — Is it true? Can you absolutely know it? How do you react when you believe it? Who would you be without it? — are specifically designed for these emotionally charged beliefs.
Try all three tools — free, no account needed